- Explore:
In November 2026, the Horseshoe Crab Management Board initiated Draft Addendum X. The Draft Addendum will consider changes to the Adaptative Resource Management (ARM) Framework, including modifying the horseshoe crab and red knot utility functions, and adding a minimum population threshold to the female horseshoe crab harvest policy function.
The ARM Framework was adopted in 2012 to manage the Delaware Bay region horseshoe crab bait fishery with consideration of horseshoe crab’s important role in the ecosystem as a food source for migratory shorebirds. Established through Addendum VII, the ARM Framework incorporates both shorebird and horseshoe crab abundance levels to set harvest levels for horseshoe crabs of Delaware Bay origin, which balance shorebird forage needs with harvester needs. Since 2013, the Board has annually reviewed recommended harvest levels from the ARM model, and specified harvest levels for the following year in the four Delaware Bay states. In 2021, a revision to the ARM Framework was completed to update and improve the ARM model with an additional decade of data on shorebirds and horseshoe crabs in the Delaware Bay region and advancements in modeling software and techniques. The Board adopted the revised ARM Framework for setting harvest specifications for the Delaware Bay region under Addendum VIII in November 2022.
Draft Addendum X responds to recommendations from the horseshoe crab stakeholder engagement process completed in 2026. Participants in this process represented groups with interests in horseshoe crab harvest management in Delaware Bay: bait harvesters, bait dealers, the biomedical industry, ecosystem conservation organizations, horseshoe crab conservation organizations, and shorebird conservation scientists and organizations. The process convened stakeholders to explore possible changes to the values-based components of the ARM Framework to better align the model with current stakeholder values. These components include the utility functions for horseshoe crabs and red knots, which assign quantitative measures of value to different levels of horseshoe crab harvest and red knot stopover abundance, and the harvest policy functions, which translate long-term projected horseshoe crab and red knot population trends into annual harvest recommendations.
Draft Addendum X will consider three changes to the ARM Framework’s utility and harvest policy functions based on recommendations with broad stakeholder agreement:
- Update the horseshoe crab harvest utility function to reflect a male-to-female bait harvest value ratio of 2.65 males per 1 female, based on values from bait harvesters and dealers.
- Update the red knot abundance utility function using values elicited from conservation stakeholders.
- Update the harvest policy function to trigger zero female harvest if the Delaware Bay population of female horseshoe crabs falls below 7 million crabs.
The Board will consider approval of Draft Addendum X for public comment in January 2027, with public hearings held in the late winter/early spring.
Phase
Status
November 2026: Board initiated Draft Addendum X
Completed
Winter 2026/2027: Plan Development Team develops Draft Addendum document for Board consideration for public comment
Active
Board considers Draft Addendum X for Public Comment
January 2027
Draft Addendum X Public Comment Period, including Public Hearings
March 2027
Board considers final approval of Addendum IX
May 2027
State Implementation of Addendum IX
TBD
Contacts
- Caitlin Starks, Senior Fishery Management Plan Coordinator, cstarks@asmfc.org or 703.842.0717
Action Development Timeline & Documents
2021
ARM Framework revised to update and improve the ARM model with an additional decade of data on shorebirds and horseshoe crabs in the Delaware Bay region and advancements in modeling software and techniques. External peer review endorses ARM revision.
November 2022
The Board adopts revised ARM Framework for setting harvest specifications for the Delaware Bay region under Addendum VIII in November 2022. ARM Framework output allows for limited female harvest for first time. Board approves male-only harvest based on overwhelming public support for the prohibition of female harvest.
Fall 2023
Board conducts stakeholder survey to better understand their diverse perspectives and values, and whether changes to horseshoe crab management for the Delaware Bay region should be considered.
July 2024
Commission holds Horseshoe Crab Management Objectives Workshop to increase understanding of various stakeholder perspectives and interests, and identify concerns, alternatives, and areas of common ground for horseshoe crab management to inform possible changes to the management program for the Delaware Bay region.
Fall 2025/Spring 2026
Board conducts a collaborative stakeholder process to inform revisions to the Delaware Bay ARM Framework. Process focused on reviewing and revising core mathematical functions of the ARM model—specifically the Utility, Reward, and Harvest Policy functions. Combined, these functions incorporate stakeholder values to determine the optimal harvest level given the estimated numbers of horseshoe crabs and red knots.
November 2026
Board initiates Draft Addendum X to consider updating the ARM utility and harvest policy functions based on stakeholder recommendations.
Next Steps
The Horseshoe Crab Management Board will consider Draft Addendum X for public comment in January 2027.
